49ers

The doink story of the 49ers in 6 chapters.

Chapter 1

Tom Wittum was a fifth-year punter, and with no other kicker on the roster, he was the de facto placekicker for the 49ers. San Francisco came to the Coliseum 0-2 and trailed 14-17 with about seven minutes left in the third quarter when Wittum lined up for a 24-yard field goal.

It was no good. The ball hit near the top of the right upright, out of frame on the broadcast video. A make would have tied the game at 17. It was the only field goal he missed in the NFL (he finished his career 1 of 2).

As if to rub salt in the wound, the Rams blocked one of Wittum's punts in the 4th quarter en route to scoring 17 unanswered points.

This was the third of four games in which Wittum handled all of San Francisco's kicking and punting. Ray Wersching took over the kicking the following week.

Chapter 2

I've watched this footage over and over again, and I am no closer to understanding what the intention of this play design was - it truly is a sight to behold. In a 7-7 4th quarter tie with less than 2 minutes to play, the Saints break the huddle and align in an exotic split alignment with the center (note - the Saints were using a longsnapper/specialist for punting, but not for field goals at this time) and 2 other linemen to the right and 5 linemen to the left and a back behind the left flank. Meanwhile, punter/holder Tom Blanchard and tragic protagonist of this weird play, Rich Szaro, are lined up behind the ball and to the left in a shockingly normal alignment for a right-footed kicker - which Szaro was not. Szaro was impressively ambidextrous for a naturally left-footed kicker, so given the chaos at the line, we'll call this normal. Then the Saints shifted into a truly vanilla field goal alignment. The architect of this play thought it'd be clever to show a right-footed attempt (for the shock value) then flip to Szaro's natural left-footed alignment.

Being a kicker in the NFL is hard. Being an ambidextrous kicker at a professional level is an incredible feat that deserves to be commended. Being asked to invert your pre-play calculus in the span of about 6 seconds is an impossible ask that leads to a very predictable outcome.

Chapter 3
No video that we've yet been able to find for this early season blowout of the Redskins by the Niners, but CBS has an old post-game write-up that calls out both of the doinks.. What happened in the aftermath was even more important - David Akers was signed by Washington to take over kicking duties. Akers's tenure in Washington would be rough, but he overcame the adversity through a fresh start in Philadelphia - the rest is history.
Chapter 4
John Kasay's 57-yard attempt as time expired initially appears to be a clean miss, and the broadcast audio calls it as such. The kick credits to the doink ledger only because the Associated Press postgame write-up flagged crossbar contact, and a frame-by-frame review confirms it. The ball's trajectory shifts ever-so-slightly as it crosses the face of the crossbar. The untouched angle would have carried the ball to the base of the goalpost; instead, it lands five yards behind the end line before skipping further backwards into the field of play. Subtle collision, but a collision. The doink stands as called.
Chapter 5

This doink came in the middle of an absolute walloping of the San Francisco 49ers at the hands of their divisional rival Seahawks. In a game decided by a final margin of 34 points, this is what OffTheUpright calls a "moot doink" - had luck broken the other way, the outcome of the game would not have been altered.

Chris Berman, narrating the game's highlights, even points out the apparent insignificance of the moment: "Doink. It's no good. Why do we show it? We'll tell you in a moment."

The reason this doink matters at all is because it was arguably as close to scoring the Niners would come on the day, and they were blanked for the first time since 1977, covering a span of 420 consecutive games.

Chapter 6
The Niners initially attempted and converted the 2-point attempt before having the try called back for holding. Instead of opting to retry the conversion, they chose to have Robbie Gould try what was now a 43 yard extra point attempt. It's a sequence that would end up having no impact on the final results, but compared to the 20 yard extra points of the pre-2015 era, this one seems like a mile.