Mathew McKelvey

Mathew McKelvey

I'm a lifelong Bengals fan, proud Daytonian and Wright State alumnus. Off the Upright is my love letter to professional football, the sometimes-absurd outcomes, and the incredible voices who've shaped the game and told its history. I'm on a mission to track every doinked kick since the NFL moved the goalposts in 1974, and to catalog the ridiculous stories and the humans amidst the chaos.

It started with a hunch: I wondered if lucky bounces off the posts impacted the psychology of the game. Doinks were a real phenomenon, but I couldn't find any data to test it, so I started building a list of doinked kicks. Then I wrote in to The Growler podcast with a hot take and my first few doinks, and they read it on air. Those became the catalog's first entries.

Transparency sits at the core of my process, because there is no industry standard for how to record contact of the ball with the upright, no standard for how to verify individual plays, and not even an official statistical definition of a doink. So the work is open: the regular-season and postseason data is available as a CSV and a free API, the Data Coverage page shows how complete it is, and published Playbook and DoinkTales pieces explain my methodology.

Writing