John Kasay's 57-yard attempt as time expired initially appears to be a clean miss, and the broadcast audio calls it as such. The kick credits to the doink ledger only because the Associated Press postgame write-up flagged crossbar contact, and a frame-by-frame review confirms it. The ball's trajectory shifts ever-so-slightly as it crosses the face of the crossbar. The untouched angle would have carried the ball to the base of the goalpost; instead, it lands five yards behind the end line before skipping further backwards into the field of play. Subtle collision, but a collision. The doink stands as called.

CAR @ NO · Dec 18, 2005 · Season 2005, 15

The Saints played their penultimate home game of 2005 in Tiger Stadium in the months after Hurricane Katrina. This doink here is a non-story, as even a "home" loss to their division rival Panthers feels unimportant.

CAR @ KC · Nov 8, 2020 · Season 2020, 9

Harrison Butker is a lot of things. In the middle of the 2020 season, he was a contributing factor in a near loss to the struggling Panthers, as Butker logs a double-doink miss. Thankfully for Butker, Panthers kicker Joey Slye was feeling a little jittery too and shanked his point after attempt, so the missed kicks ended up as a wash.

View all 4 stories →

Doinks by Panthers (21)

Record in doink games: 7-14 · Record with made doink: 2-3

Date	Game	Kicker	Type	Dist	Qtr	Result	W/L
Sep 282025	CAR @ NECAR 13, NE 42	Ryan Fitzgerald	XP	33	1	No Good	L
Dec 102023	CAR @ NOCAR 6, NO 28	Eddy Pineiro	FG	41	4	No Good	L
Nov 102022	ATL @ CARATL 15, CAR 25	Eddy Pineiro	FG	46	1	Good	W
Oct 242021	CAR @ NYGCAR 3, NYG 25	Zane Gonzalez	FG	45	1	Good	L
Aug 272021	PIT @ CARPIT 9, CAR 34	Ryan Santoso	FG	52	1	Good	W
Nov 82020	CAR @ KCCAR 31, KC 33 High Impact	Joey Slye	FG	51	3	No Good	L
Sep 122019	TB @ CARTB 20, CAR 14	Joey Slye	FG	51	3	Good	L
Dec 302018	CAR @ NOCAR 33, NO 14	Chandler Catanzaro	XP	33	1	No Good	W
Nov 182018	CAR @ DETCAR 19, DET 20 High Impact	Graham Gano	FG	34	3	No Good	L
Feb 72016	CAR @ DENCAR 10, DEN 24 Super Bowl	Graham Gano	FG	44	3	No Good	L
Oct 282012	CAR @ CHICAR 22, CHI 23	Justin Medlock	FG	45	4	Good	L
Nov 282010	CAR @ CLECAR 23, CLE 24 Game-Loser	John Kasay	FG	42	4	No Good	L
Sep 22010	CAR @ PITCAR 3, PIT 19	John Kasay	FG	51	1	No Good	L
Jan 152006	CAR @ CHICAR 29, CHI 21 Playoffs	John Kasay	XP	33	4	No Good	W
Dec 182005	CAR @ NOCAR 27, NO 10	John Kasay	FG	50	4	No Good	W
Jan 102004	CAR @ STLCAR 29, STL 23 Playoffs	John Kasay	FG	53	4	No Good	W
Oct 132002	CAR @ DALCAR 13, DAL 14 High Impact	Shayne Graham	FG	44	2	No Good	L
Oct 282001	NYJ @ CARNYJ 13, CAR 12 High Impact	John Kasay	XP	33	1	No Good	L
Nov 81998	CAR @ SFCAR 23, SF 25 Game-Loser	John Kasay	FG	57	4	No Good	L
Aug 221998	MIN @ CARMIN 25, CAR 22 Game-Loser	John Kasay	FG	43	4	No Good	L
Oct 291995	CAR @ NECAR 20, NE 17 High Impact	John Kasay	FG	39	4	No Good	W

Doinks against Panthers (24)

Record in doink games: 11-13 · Record vs. made doink: 2-2

Date	Game	Kicker	Team	Type	Dist	Qtr	Result	W/L
Aug 252023	DET @ CARDET 26, CAR 17	Riley Patterson	DET	FG	53	1	No Good	L
Jan 22022	CAR @ NOCAR 10, NO 18	Brett Maher	NO	XP	33	4	No Good	L
Nov 282021	CAR @ MIACAR 10, MIA 33	Jason Sanders	MIA	XP	33	3	No Good	L
Dec 132020	DEN @ CARDEN 32, CAR 27	Brandon McManus	DEN	XP	33	1	No Good	L
Nov 82020	CAR @ KCCAR 31, KC 33	Harrison Butker	KC	XP	33	4	No Good	L
Dec 152019	SEA @ CARSEA 30, CAR 24	Jason Myers	SEA	XP	33	1	No Good	L
Dec 82019	CAR @ ATLCAR 20, ATL 40	Younghoe Koo	ATL	FG	50	4	Good	L
Nov 32019	TEN @ CARTEN 20, CAR 30	Ryan Succop	TEN	FG	44	4	No Good	W
Dec 92018	CAR @ CLECAR 20, CLE 26	Greg Joseph	CLE	XP	33	4	No Good	L
Oct 12017	CAR @ NECAR 33, NE 30	Stephen Gostkowski	NE	FG	58	2	Good	W
Sep 172017	BUF @ CARBUF 3, CAR 9	Steven Hauschka	BUF	FG	45	4	Good	W
Oct 102016	TB @ CARTB 17, CAR 14	Roberto Aguayo	TB	FG	33	2	No Good	L
Sep 252016	MIN @ CARMIN 22, CAR 10	Graham Gano	MIN	FG	54	2	No Good	L
Oct 42015	CAR @ TBCAR 37, TB 23	Kyle Brindza	TB	FG	29	2	No Good	W
Dec 202009	MIN @ CARMIN 7, CAR 26	Ryan Longwell	MIN	FG	39	1	No Good	W
Dec 62009	TB @ CARTB 6, CAR 16	Connor Barth	TB	FG	36	2	No Good	W
Dec 82008	TB @ CARTB 23, CAR 38	Matt Bryant	TB	FG	40	1	No Good	W
Nov 92008	CAR @ OAKCAR 17, OAK 6 Game-Loser	Sebastian Janikowski	OAK	FG	58	4	No Good	W
Oct 292006	DAL @ CARDAL 35, CAR 14	Mike Vanderjagt	DAL	FG	48	1	No Good	L
Oct 52003	NO @ CARNO 13, CAR 19	John Carney	NO	FG	57	2	No Good	W
Aug 102000	PIT @ CARPIT 0, CAR 13	Kris Brown	PIT	FG	54	4	No Good	W
Sep 261999	CIN @ CARCIN 3, CAR 27	Doug Pelfrey	CIN	FG	31	3	No Good	W
Sep 271998	GB @ CARGB 37, CAR 30	Ryan Longwell	GB	XP	33	1	No Good	L
Sep 131998	CAR @ NOCAR 14, NO 19	Doug Brien	NO	FG	56	3	Good	L